
I took Audrey to a park today, near the Parnell Rose Gardens. Adjoining the park is a childcare facility. They've since removed the sign but I was always a little alarmed at the fact that they took in babies from three months of age.
So we're at the park and I hear a small fiery cry, and I know from experience times two that this is not the cry of a toddler but of a baby. I nonchalently walk with Audrey nearer to the scene (in my mind I am sprinting). It's midday at the centre, lunchtime I guess, and there is a little girl dressed in a pretty white frilly top and pants, and she is sitting down outside, completely alone. Her eyes are red from the length of time she has been crying. It's heartbreaking. What astonished me, and still does a day later, is that no-one came over to her for about thirty minutes. They left her to cry. I went over to the fence and spoke to her through the bars, and in all honesty it felt like I was speaking to a pet in a cage. I rolled a green ball to her through the bars and she stopped crying. I moved away after a short chat with her, and went back to Audrey. She started crying again, and still no-one came. When the centre staff were aware that I and another father were quietly observing this they called out to her in some casual manner, more for our benefit than hers. She kept crying. A while later Audrey and I went back to her, and so did the father and his daughter. She seemed keen for attention, keen for a swing, a hug, anything. Almost immediately a young woman came out, scooped her up and told her how 'silly' she was being. The child might have been around 8 months old, but she was tiny so looked even more helpless. I said 'it's heartbreaking to see her like this '. She remarked bluntly 'what?'. I repeated myself. The young woman turned to the little baby and said 'oh you've been cross all day' and then she took her back into the centre, out of sight. The father turned to me and said 'that remark could have only come from a woman who has never had a child'. It's the first time I felt I could have taken another child home. I wanted to hug her.
Because I am sure many of you have children in childcare, I'd like to point out that what I saw was most unusual, unusual enough for me to approach the child several times and to speak to the childcare person. It was a sad sight. And I guess she is back there again today, being 'silly' and 'cross'.
I do know just how tough times are. In saying that I wish stay-at-home mothers were encouraged more, instead of being viewed as having no ambition or worth. I have seen a little of this attitude, but amazingly almost all my friends are stay-at-home mothers. Maybe it just works out that way, like attracts like. Or situation attracts situation. I know I would find it very hard to work for someone else and leave my children for the day. I don't think I'm that strong. And I am very thankful we haven't had to make that choice. In New Zealand the government offers financial incentives for mothers to get back to work. Stay-at-home mothers get absolutely nothing, not even after paying tax like I have for seventeen working years. I have changed my spending habits though. When I worked full time I could buy whatever I liked. Now a lot more thought goes into it, and I can't always buy what I fancy. But it's a compromise I am very happy with.
P.S. The incredible picture above is by the talented Lisa Golightly of Kiki and Polly. I won Cup of Jo's Friday giveaway! I am beyond thrilled and plan on ordering a large Girl in a Yellow Suit.
Wow! You won out of 800+ entries? You must feel very lucky.
ReplyDeleteDaycare was never an option for us. My husband and I agreed early on even before we married (and have kids) that one of us will stay home with kids until they reach school age. I know for many other families, this is not an option and they have to reply on daycare facilities. I only wish public and private sectors will invest more in helping working families with young children. Longer maternity leave, work site child care, etc. It is heartbreaking to read this.
your story made me want to cry..I know that daycare and have often noticed the lack of caregivers around to look after the children. I am with you on the stay at home Mum thing...It is a hard job! Sometimes I really believe going to work would be easier! My little guy does go to pre school 2 days a week part time and he loves it. I felt really guilty at the beginning but it allows me to spend some real quality time with my little baby Freya (without the tantrums ;))
ReplyDeleteThat is a heartbreaking story!! I'm a stay-at-home mom and we live in Los Angeles, where it's very expensive. i cannot imagine leaving my my girls at a day care all day long, just so I can go back to work and keep up a life style that most people live out here. I don't judge other moms who work. We all have to do what we think is best for our families. but for me, staying home with my kids is the best thing.
ReplyDeleteSo so sad for that child, and the parents who dont know about it. My understanding is that 'qualified' carers have to look after the littlest one. Her words show no understanding of the needs of a small child, in fact the opposite. An older child would be able to go up and demand what they needed. until my daughter is old enough to demand what she needs and tell me when she gets home if she didn't get it, my kid wont be going near one of those places...and I wont be getting an iphone, or a flash holiday until then and that my preference x
ReplyDeleteHeartbreaking isn't it? That baby is probably younger than my baby and i could never leave her to cry like that. Makes you feel so sad for the mother who would have no idea this is going on. I do think it happens quite often because the number of carers to babies just doesn't add up.
ReplyDeleteThough we are financially worse off and can't afford fancy holidays and cars etc, I feel that for me being at home with the kids is the best decision we have made.
I stayed home for 1.5 years, although it wasn't maternity leave because I was expected to continue doing work. this was probably one of the most stressful moments for me: no income, no possibility of a job unless degree was completed, and no childcare assistance (family or nannies).
ReplyDeleteThis time I won't have maternity leave either in spite of Canada's generous family policy because I'm not technically an employee. The baby will be 5 months come daycare. I'm not happy about it, but I need to go on the market that fall, and having daycare is absolutely essential during that time.
Catherine, Well done for speaking up when so many wouldn't have. I was shocked by what you saw and I am sure the little girl's parents would be heartbroken to know their precious baby's needs were ignored. I agree that stay-at-home mum's should receive the same entitlements as working mothers...why discriminate?. I will go back to my part-time position when Miette is 14 months but I am lucky that my partner and my Mum will look after her when I need to work. Motherhood has certainly changed me and it is liberating to not need as much 'stuff' and to simply enjoy the experience of watching my children grow...priceless.
ReplyDeleteOh that poor child, I guess it serves as a reminder to choose your childcare very carefully especially for babies. I've been lucky enough to work only very part time and so only needed a maximum of about 15 hrs a week in care from age 2 on - most of it with a wonderful home based carer ( she has huge waiting lists - word gets around when they are good). Your story makes me want to wait outside and see who picks up that child to tell them what you saw.
ReplyDeleteHi Catherine, I read your story and my heart broke for the little one. Very good you'd spoken to the girl who was supposed to tend the child?!
ReplyDeleteI'm a stay-home-mum and I'm happy we've made the decision at the time, although in The Netherlands it's still not really 'accepted' especially by other career-women.
Take care!
My heart broke a little reading this. I am Norwegian and here we get 15 months of maternity leave with full pay if you add up the months mums and dads are allocated. Most places you can take 2 years additionally with no pay. I know compared to most places that is luxury. In addition childcare is relatively cheap compared to income level. As the system caters well for mothers who want to go back to work when the baby is 1years old and property prices are relatively high, most women choose to go back to work and leave their kiids in daycare. What is a shame is that if you choose to stay home for longer or start working part time people tend to look at you as if you are a bit of an idiot, hysterical about your child's wellbeing or some oldfashioned housewife stuck with a 1950s value system. I work for a large corporation and constantly have to defend why I work part time. This really annoys me.
ReplyDeletethis post has saddened me in so many ways, i used to find these sorts of scenarios difficult enough before i was a mother now it makes me angry inside when i see people being so negligent to children, when did we lose our instincts for love and care and compassion, i also value your comments about the lack of support for mothers in nz, i am lucky enough to have a partner willing to work to support all of us, my heart goes out to the single mothers of nz.
ReplyDeletegood to have insights like yours, helpful and sincere...love the painting!
ReplyDeleteWhat a heartbreaking story.
ReplyDeleteI used to work and travel a ton. I had planned to go back to work 2 months after I had my first child, and after having her I couldn't imagine going back to work. All my colleagues and friends were shocked. For me, it was the right thing to do. You don't know it's for you until it happens to you.
I do a little freelance writing now on the side and hope I will be able to make a "real" living doing this as the girls get older and go to school, but right now being home with them is the best decision I've made. I detest when I hear friends say "I wish I could stay at home like you," and I see them driving new cars, carrying expensive purses, go on big vacations. I always want to say "you can, if you really want to." It's okay if you don't want to, but don't say you "wish you could" like it's a luxury they can't afford.
What a heartbreaking story. How could a child be treating with so little love and attention. Especially, a baby that young. It makes me angry just to imagine what you saw. Living in Paris, we could not financially afford for one of us to stay home, but we are extremely lucky to have a great childminder for our son. I have heard many (too many) stories like this one where nannies are "violent" to the children in their punishments. If only someone could tell the parents what was going on, I am sure they would be horrified. I would want to know if someone were being negligent towards my little boy.
ReplyDeleteI have felt like I am alone in these thoughts for so long so am so glad to see I'm not alone. An extension of this is that often i feel that the media portrays that women should WANT to be career oriented and WANT to work and have the kids in childcare. That those who stay home are old fashioned. I wish the media represented we (and in australia I am sure there is a significant percentage) who chose to go without luxuries/holidays/technology upgrades/new clothes etc just so we can stay home and be there for the children, and don't necessarily have career ambition. Who is representing us in the media and saying its ok to feel this way? thanks for your post
ReplyDelete